Jim Shoemaker owns a business that
he built from the ground up over his lifetime. He would like to leave the business
to his son and daughter and has worried about their ability to beat the competition
if they become saddled with estate taxes after his death. Therefore, Jim was
glad to hear that changes in tax law resulting from the Taxpayer Relief Act
of 1997 might enable him to get a break on his estate taxes. So he’s wondering
whether he qualifies and what the new deduction is worth.
If Jim’s business qualifies, up
to $675,000 of the value of his business can be deducted from his estate before
estate taxes are calculated. When added to his 1998 applicable gift and estate
tax exclusion amount of $625,000, the total nontaxable portion of his estate
is $1.3 million. Jim is disappointed to learn, though, that the total amount
will not increase above $1.3 million. That’s because when you qualify for the
family-owned business interest deduction, you give up some of the increases
in the applicable exclusion amount.
Is Jim Qualified?
Jim was born and raised in the
U. S., so he meets the requirement that he be either a United States citizen
or resident and also that the business not be a foreign business. Since Jim
started the business in his garage in 1958, he easily meets the requirement
that the business have been owned by him or a member of his family for five
of the eight years immediately preceding the time he dies. Jim and his family
meet the requirement that they own at least 50% of the business. If Jim wanted
to accept an offer from a business associate to sell part of the business, he
would need to retain at least 30% of the business after the sale to still qualify
for the deduction.
The Heirs
Jim will leave the business primarily
to his son and daughter, so he will meet the requirement that the business either
pass to or be acquired by a qualified heir. Qualified heirs generally include
spouse, ancestors and lineal descendants.
Jim is also considering different
ways to include his right hand-man, Luke Johnson, in his plans. Luke has been
an employee of the business since 1968. Jim is glad to know that he might be
able to enter into a buy-sell agreement with Luke or that he could leave a portion
of the business to Luke without jeopardizing his deduction, because the law
allows an employee of 10 years or more to be considered a qualified heir.
Personal Holding Company Status
Jim’s company was never involved
in offering marketable securities and has not received more than 35% of its
income as personal holding company income. Although the business is doing well,
Jim does not have much cash or many marketable securities in excess of his day-to-day
working capital needs, which could disqualify his business.
Portion of the Estate
Most of Jim’s wealth is tied up
in the business, so he should have no trouble meeting the requirement that his
business represent at least 50% of his adjusted gross estate on his death. Just
the same, Jim will have his advisors run a calculation that will use the complex
statutory formula to account for his past gifts of part of the business to his
children, his debts and other statutory factors.
Material Participation
Jim intends to continue working,
and his children both work in the business full-time. They easily meet the requirement
that he or a member of his family must have materially participated inthe business
for five of the eight years immediately preceding his death. Jim is glad to
know that there are special rules for retirement and disability (and surviving
spouses) in case something should happen to him.
Jim’s children are not concerned
about a recapture of tax excluded. They intend to continue working in the business
and have no intention of selling or moving the business or themselves out of
the country in the next 10 years.
Jim Qualifies, Do You?
Jim’s glad. His business meets
all requirements for the family-owned business deduction, and his heirs will
be spared a lot of tax on his estate. You, too, may be eligible for this significant
new deduction.
As this article goes to press,
there is a technical corrections bill pending. This article has outlined the
changes to the family-owned business deduction as set forth in the bill. It
is well worth the time to determine if your business would qualify. Please let
us know ifyou have any questions about the family-owned business deduction or
would like assistance in determining if you qualify. We would welcome the opportunity
to help you minimize taxes on your estate.
What Are Recapture Events?
A portion of the family and business
exclusion can be recaptured and taxes may be due if any of the following events
occur:
- The qualified heir fails to materially
participate in the business for at least five of the eight years during the
10-year period following the decedent’s death.
- The qualified heir disposes of
all or part of the interest to someone other than a family member.
- The qualified heir becomes disqualified
by losing U.S. citizenship, ceasing to be a lawful permanent U.S. resident or
commencing residency in a foreign country that has a treaty with the United
States.
- The business’s principal place of business ceases to be in the United States.
How are amounts previously excluded
from the estate later recaptured? Eachqualified heir is potentially responsible
for a portion of the tax equal to his or her percentage interest in the business.
This recapture tax applies on an event-by-event basis. A recapture event occurring
with respect to one heir will not necessarily mean that other heirs will owe
recapture tax.
The recapture tax equals a percentage
of the estate tax that would have been imposed if the business had been included
in the decedent’s estate. If a recapture event occurs during the first six years
of material participation, the total amount of the reduction in the estate tax
attributable to the qualified heir’s interest must be recaptured. Smaller amounts
are recaptured if the event occurs after six years.